If your part of a middle class or higher household, you probably have an mp3 player. And if you have a lot of music, you probably have a hard drive player. And if you have a hard drive player, you probably have an Apple iPod, Creative Zen, or possibly a Microsoft Zune.
My first hard drive based MP3 player ever was a 30gb Creative Zen. It was a fantastic MP3 player for the money. I think it came with some computer software, but you didn’t need it, it installed itself as a removable disk, you copied MP3’s over to it, it organized them via id3 tags itself and presented you your library. It worked very well, had good battery life, and suited me perfectly. Then I dropped it.
So I was in the market for a new mp3 player. My music library had grown considerably at this point, I wanted the biggest player I could buy. Creative at that point wasn’t in the business of large hard drive players anymore. Microsoft had the Zune coming up, but only in a 30gb model. However, Apple had just released the 80gb iPod. So I decided to get the iPod.
After about 6 months with it, lets go over what’s good about it. The main reason to have an iPod, is that EVERYONE has an iPod. It’s not about being trendy, it’s not about fitting in, it’s about having support for your device. Accessories, troubleshooting, software. It’s all available for the iPod. This is pretty much the only reason to have an iPod. The interface is ok, the clickwheel is cool, yeah, whatever. Quite frankly, the Creative Vision:M is much slicker on all fronts, but it simply doesn’t have the 3rd party accessory support. If you have a newer car audio deck, chances are it has iPod support. Not Zune or Zen support… iPod. Want a car mount? They are easy to find for the iPod, not so much for the Zune or Zen, sorry. Also, I like the TV out cable accessory. So, that’s why I still have an iPod despite everything you’re about to read.
iPod problem one: lack of sorting options. It seems like sorting by album artist is such a simple feature for an mp3 player. Your iPod doesn’t have this. In fact your iPod doesn’t have a lot of things as far as sorting goes on the device. Apple’s iPod is extremely accessible… but this comes at a cost to those of us that really want to use the device we want to, not the way Apple wants us to. Oh well.
iPod problem two: it’s slow. You might say, “hey, my iPod is fast”, but I’m willing to bet you have less than 40gb of music on it. If you load a full 80gb iPod up with 5 minute songs… it will not go fast. The processor simply cannot handle the advertised 20,000 songs. From what I can tell is that the iPod is designed to hold about 30gb to 50gb of music, and then some videos, in which case it works great, and is now how I use my iPod. But video is never really what I wanted. Oh well.
iPod problem three: iTunes. iTunes is a horrible piece of music management software… if you have a large library. Once your library breaks 100gb or so, your iTunes will not go fast. It will take up more than 150mb of system memory. It will not be the “killer app” it may have been. It also takes forever to process and add music to the library. Oh well.
iPod problem four: video. Good luck getting your own videos on the iPod. Unless you shell out the cash for one of the commercial “dvd to ipod” or “video to ipod” converters. If you want to this for free, there are a couple alternatives but they aren’t “user friendly”. iTunes will also convert certain QuickTime compatible formats into iPod compatible files. Assuming that you take an entire TV series and convert it to an iPod compatible format, your in for a treat as you go through iTunes and individually tag each episode as a TV Show and also set the Season, Episode Number, and Episode ID. VLC is useful for converting, and Atomic Parsley helps with tagging, but these are not for your average iPod carrying teenage girl. Oh yeah, or you can buy everything from the iTunes store.
Despite all this, iPod will be the only option until by some miracle another company gains enough market share to spawn third party accessory support like the iPod has.